Sunday, 10 May 2015

Sorry Bill there has always been a two-tier justice system in New Zealand


University of Law Professor Bill Hodge is correct when stating he was "concerned to see a run of cases where athletes were discharged without conviction, on the basis it would affect their employment and their ability to travel or compete in international competitions.”

"It's just a bit concerning that it seems to be setting up a two-tier system of justice, where one class of people get one form of justice, and a different class of people get a different form.”

His statement comes in light of Blues player George Moala's discharge without conviction.

Only Professor Bill should have replaced the word ‘athlete'; with the word ‘rugby player’.

New Zealand triathletes, rowers, soccer players are after-all all athletes.

Where is their ’get out of jail free’ card?

Last week ex Auckland Grammar student Moala was found guilty of one charge of assault with intent to injure.

What would the chances of escaping conviction under the same circumstances if you were a supermarket worker?

You told your probation officer “I not guilty” and denied your role away from court? 

Nil!

No judge would care if you wanted to travel overseas at some future stage and the conviction would impinge those plans if you were a mechanic or a truck-driver.

This is such an outrage that I wouldn’t be surprised if we saw listings in the Yellow Pages giving Joe-Blogs facing prosecution the ability – at a price - to all solicit the support of ex All Blacks, since clearly their “He is a good guy” references gain sway with N.Z judges.

The crime of assault with intent to injure has a precedent case on its books which reduces what is a serious offence to below that of a traffic fine.

When you get a traffic fine you get a record.  

Yet another, shameful day for N.Z justice. 

 

Wednesday, 28 January 2015

The principal of the law in New Zealand applying evenly to all its citizens is again in tatters.


 “All indications are you can go all the way in rugby”

‘All the way’ being a metaphor for The All Blacks.

So fucking what Gus Andree Wiltens?

The judge who just failed to convict young Blues wing Tevita Li for drink driving.

Li who plead guilty to the charges, only having the minor inconvenience of having to reimburse the costs for the blood tests.

Regardless of whether the conviction would have impinged his prospects as a sheet metal worker, Work and Income clerk, lawyer etc. - he should be held to account.  

In a farcical Gilbertese twist Li wants to join the Police force after playing pro rugby!  

The New Zealand Judicial system must be a global laughing stock, credibility on par with an African dictatorship.

The principal of the law applying to all its citizens is again in tatters.  
 
One rule for Rugby law-breakers another for you and me.
 
 

Saturday, 17 January 2015

Blues and NZRFU Cover-up Peter Saili Incident


A new Super 15 is almost upon us and yet, at this 11th hour The Blues have terminated the contract of Peter Saili. 

He’s off to play in France. 

Why? 

Because he’s chasing big money doesn’t cut the mustard.  

There was an ‘off-field’ incident according to The Sunday News (18th Jan)   

So what was this incident The Blues/NZRFU are sweeping under the carpet?  

The real reason Peter Saili is departing our shores? 

Nothing to do with a household appliance being wrapped around a young teen, one surmises?

Sunday, 11 January 2015

Blues player George Moala ticks all the boxes when it comes to drunken violence


It’s only a couple of weeks into 2015 and New Zealand Courts have seen their first high profile rugby player appear. 

Let me take a rough guess.

A complete stab in the dark as to what happened…… 

Assault, brawl?  

Booze?  

Wee smalls? 

Correct!  

Wow, I must have extrasensory powers.
 
I mean according to the NZRFU these events are rare, in line with other sporting demographics like N.Z Rowers and International Triathletes etc who similarly litter N.Z media with their misdeeds.

Wednesday, 17 December 2014

Coroner blames Rugby Booze Culture for two deaths.


[Stuff NZ] The deaths of two young rugby players in a high speed crash could have been avoided if a culture of mixing drinking with sport was not so prevalent. Jack Henry Ballantyne and Tui Huruata Candish-Thompson died on May 11, 2012, after crashing into a power pole at high speed near Hinds, south of Ashburton. Ballantyne had been drinking alcohol and was driving about 185kmh when he lost control of the vehicle on the rural road.

Candish-Thompson was in the front passenger seat of the car when the crash happened. In findings released today, Coroner Richard McElrea said the deaths were a "tragedy that could have been avoided". "It was an example of the mixture of sport and alcohol." The two teenagers had visited the Hinds Tavern after rugby training on May 10 – something the team regularly did after practice.

 The coroner has clearly made the wrong conclusion. 

At least according to Steve Tew who consistently plugs the line there is no drinking culture in N.Z Rugby circles.   

Try telling the poor parents.
 

Wednesday, 10 December 2014

Police Custody is the best place for Pita Wilson

 

Four people, including ex Southland/North Harbour player Pita Wilson have been variously been charged with kidnap, serious violence and methamphetamine-related offending in Central Otago. 

Wilson made the Southland Stags in 2003 after playing for North Harbour. 

Also a former cage-fighter Wilson is a right bit of works. 

In 2006 Wilson was shot during a gang confrontation on The Gold Coast.  

Pita Wilson is a proud product of both Waitaki Boys and Otago Boys High School.

So good he made the New Zealand Secondary Schoolboys team.  

The coach of Wilsons local Wakatipu club premier team, Damian ‘Dippers’ Petre labelled Wilson a “huge asset”.  

I’m sure the police and non-rugby circles have other words to describe Pita Wilson.  




 
 


Dunedin Judge Confirms Rugby’s Privileged Position




Fracture a blokes jaw, punch one of his front teeth out, in a drunken piece of late night street thuggery. 

All because the bloke made a feeble remark about the rugby club jersey you were wearing.   

What would you expect the punishment to be in a case like this? 

An assault conviction would surely be the minimum?  

Unless of course you are an up and coming Otago rugby starlet like Riley McDowall and not say a clerk in a government department. 

As I am at pains to indicate there is a separate law in New Zealand for Rugby players and Judge Kevin Phillips has merely re-confirmed this by discharging this drunken punk without conviction.